The Best Cheeseburgers in Lafayette From Places That Aren’t Known for Cheeseburgers

In celebration of National Cheeseburger Day on September 18, we decided to ask Acadiana locals a simple yet delicious question: Where can you find the best cheeseburger in Lafayette from a place that’s not known for burgers? The responses we received revealed some hidden gems across Lafayette and beyond, showing that great burgers aren’t just confined to burger joints.

Here are some of the top spots that might surprise you with how good their burgers are:

1. Green Oaks Lounge

Known as a smoky, hole-in-the-wall bar and pool hall tucked away on Guilbeau Road, Green Oaks Lounge offers a cheeseburger that regulars rave about.

It's the kind of place where you can sink into a booth with a burger that’s just as comforting as the atmosphere.

2. Legends of Lafayette

With multiple locations in town, Legends is primarily a bar. But did you know their burger game is strong?

Locals swear by this low-key gem, which originally started flipping burgers on George Foreman grills at their Bertrand Drive spot.

3. Dean-O’s Pizza

Sure, they’re known for pizza, but Dean-O’s proves they can do more than pies.

Their burger has been a go-to for years, combining everything you love about comfort food in one juicy bite.

4. Alesi Pizza House

Another pizza joint with a burger surprise, Alesi’s has long been a Lafayette staple.

While pizza might bring you in the door, their burger will keep you coming back.

5. Adopted Dog Brewery

Known for craft beer, Adopted Dog Brewery is quietly serving up one of the best smash burgers in town.

The combination of fresh beer and a well-crafted burger is hard to beat.

6. Kevin’s Seafood

It might seem odd to look for a burger at a seafood spot, but at Kevin’s Seafood on Moss Street and Ambassador Caffery, the burger options make it worth the trip.

7. El Paso Mexican Restaurant

El Paso is beloved for its tacos and margaritas, but the burger here is like a fiesta in your mouth.

Don’t overlook this hidden gem next time you’re in the mood for something other than tacos.

8. Ochsner Lafayette General Medical Center

Surprisingly, hospital food gets a gold star here!

Whether you're visiting a patient or just happen to be nearby, the food at Lafayette General’s cafeteria has earned a reputation—especially their cheeseburger.

9. Red Lerille’s Health & Racquet Club

Famous for fitness, Red’s is also a spot where you can indulge in a delicious burger before (or after) hitting the gym.

Talk about balance!

10. Mama’s Fried Chicken

Located in Opelousas, Mama’s is known for fried chicken, but their burger is one that deserves just as much attention.

Next time you're grabbing your fried favorites, don’t forget to add a burger to the mix.

11. Bonefish Grill

Yes, they specialize in seafood, but don’t sleep on their burger.

It's a fish-free bite of heaven for those who want something different.

12. Spoonbill Watering Hole & Restaurant

Known for seafood mastery, Spoonbill’s burger is one of the worst-kept secrets in town.

With one of the top chefs on the Gulf Coast at the helm, the quality of their burger is no surprise.

13. Don’s Seafood

Seafood might be the star of the show at Don’s, but their burger is worthy of the spotlight too.

Locals say it’s a must-try.

14. Y-Not Stop

This Youngsville-Broussard gas station is not just about filling up your tank; you’ll want to fill up on one of their burgers, too.

This place proves that sometimes the best food comes from the most unexpected places.

 Other Acadiana Favorites

The burger love doesn’t stop in Lafayette. In Breaux Bridge, The Fruit Stand has been a longtime favorite, while Max’s Pool Hall in Abbeville, Moo-Noo’s in Erath, and A-Bears in New Iberia are all spots people insist you check out for their burgers. Even places like LeMarche in Maurice and Shade Tree in Broussard get honorable mentions for their unexpected burger goodness.

If you’re looking for more burger inspiration, there were over 300 suggestions from locals eager to share their favorites. The hunt for the best cheeseburger in town is literally endless.

Grab any of your burger-loving friends from the group chat and explore these local spots—you may just discover a new favorite in a place you’d least expect.